FREE SHIPPING $45+ Use Code: FREESHIP45 | Details

Home » Shop » Love’s a Mystery Book 1: Sleepy Hollow, NY

Love’s a Mystery Book 1: Sleepy Hollow, NY

Enjoy two sparkling old-fashioned romances in one book – set hundreds of years apart – and woven together with suspenseful mystery in a small-town with a peculiar name.

FREE GIFT with purchase: A lovely durable floral tote with inspiring quote with Book 1 or series purchase! 

Read a FREE Excerpt!



Product Name Qty


#html-body [data-pb-style=OXJC6KQ]{justify-content:flex-start;display:flex;flex-direction:column;background-position:left top;background-size:cover;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-attachment:scroll}

Love’s a Mystery in Sleepy Hollow, NY is the first book in Guideposts new romantic mystery series.

Each book in this exciting series contains not one but two memorable stories set in charming small towns with odd names all across America. Your first adventure begins in the small town of Sleepy Hollow, New York, made famous by Washington Irving’s Legend of Sleepy Hollow.

When a strange man claiming to be the brother of Ichabod Crane accuses Brom Van Brundt of murdering Ichabod, his daughter Hannie begins a desperate search for the truth. Was the local folklore true? Was Brom the headless horsemen who scared Ichabod out of Sleepy Hollow? Or did something more sinister happen? The handsome new schoolmaster, Gideon, offers to help Hannie, but how long can they hide their growing feelings for one another?

Then turn the page and travel 200 years to the present where Tess has returned to Sleepy Hollow to help run her Gran’s soup shop. But all is not well. Gran has been scammed out of thousands of dollars by a bogus animal charity. She hires Riley O’Toole, Tess’s high school crush, to help. As Riley and Tess investigate, sparks soon fly. Is Gran secretly playing matchmaker?

Escape into sweet stories of unexpected love, small-town goodness, tantalizing mystery and happy endings. No matter where these books take you – Sleepy Hollow, NY, Cape Disappointment, WA, Cut and Shoot, TX – you’ll see that true romance is alive and well.

Order now and receive a FREE GIFT – a lovely floral tote with a Book 1 or series purchase. A $15.95 value – a FREE!

Book Details:

Format: Hardcover

Length: 284 pages

Size:  5 ½ x 8 ½


Scroll to Top