Amish Fiction

As Thanksgiving approaches, many businesses along Sugarcreek’s Main Street have reported incidents of theft! With the safety of her gift shop’s inventory at stake, Cheryl becomes motivated to get to the bottom of these crimes. Her investigation leads to many potential suspects, including an individual who has been secretly living out of Naomi and Seth Miller’s winter buggy! Will Cheryl find the culprit before the residents of Sugarcreek suffer more serious economic casualties? Read on in this tale of empathy and compassion in the cozy community of Sugarcreek!

Cheryl’s assistant at the Swiss Miss Gift Shop, Lydia Troyer, has received a mysterious message from an unknown number claiming to have information regarding Lydia’s cousin, Mark Troyer. While many believed that Mark left Sugarcreek to pursue opportunities outside of the Amish community, Lydia has had her doubts. Will Cheryl and her friends in Sugarcreek be able to close the books on this case, or will the Troyer family have to accept the idea that they may never know what happened to Mark?

Naomi and Seth Miller have had a lot of tension building up between them lately, and Cheryl wants to help bring them together for Valentine’s Day. Nothing is ever as simple as it seems, however, and as Cheryl receives help investigating their relationship from an unlikely source, she uncovers the events of one fateful summer day…  Could this be the force that has been driving Naomi and Seth farther apart each day? 

The discovery of an old laundry chute in the Swiss Miss Gift Shop reignites the mystery of a woman who disappeared long ago in Sugarcreek! Is there a connection between the two? Meanwhile, Cheryl’s parents and her brother, Matt, are in town to visit, but will family tensions threaten to break their relationship with one another? Will a family’s love be enough to overcome the forces that threaten to drive them apart?

Following the death of Seth’s Uncle Silas, the Miller family is spending time mourning the loss of a loved one. Meanwhile, Levi is relieved to hear that he will inherit land from Silas, but will the arrival of a shady developer—coinciding with the disappearance of the deed to Silas’s land—threaten Levi’s ownership of the property? As always, Cheryl and her friends from Sugarcreek are on the case!

Albert Yoder has been arrested for illegally distributing and selling raw milk across county lines, and his wife has had to be rushed to the hospital to give birth! As a result, Cheryl and Naomi offer to assist Albert’s six young daughters with maintaining the farm— all while investigating a few suspect relationships between Albert’s dairy farm and multiple shady figures. Was Albert in over his head, and was he hiding something from his family? With the overwhelming wealth of suspect circumstances, will this mystery prove to be too much for even Cheryl and Naomi to solve?